Philadelphia: A City Rich With History
Philadelphians know their stuff when it comes to their place in history.
Philadelphia comes face to face with its history every day, often in ways that make it impossible to separate past from present. In Boston, what you’ll find are memorials to a limited period of history -- from the Boston Massacre in 1770 to the British evacuation on March 17, 1776. From then on, the activity shifted south, centering, of course, on Philadelphia. Here, history finds you.
One summer evening, the vestry (parish council) of the venerable St. Peter’s Episcopal Church at Third and Pine Streets was meeting in its parish building across the street from the church. The doorbell rang, and a teenager, whose father was at the meeting, answered the door. There, on the step, in full costume, was Ralph Archbold, who makes his living portraying Benjamin Franklin. Archbold was looking for a key to the church for a concert he was hosting.
“I thought you were dead,” the teenager said, as he stared at Archbold. “But,” the boy quickly added, “I’m glad you’re OK.”
Archbold plays his part so well that when he and Linda Wilde, who impersonates Betsy Ross at the Betsy Ross House at Third and Arch streets, tied the knot at Independence Hall and in front of thousands of residents on July 3, 2008, Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter officiated, and the Philly Pops played the Wedding March. The couple were taken by carriage a few blocks to City Tavern, at Second and Walnut streets, which the park service has re-created from 18th century plans. They dined with George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and other re-enactors.
Here, locals and visitors are encouraged to experience history. Museums like Colonial Williamsburg and Plimoth Plantation are scripted re-creations of America’s early past, where the 17th and 18th centuries are frozen in time.
Filming the Real Deal
In the 1983 CBS-TV miniseries George Washington, the Head House at Second and Pine streets in Society Hill doubled as the long-ago-demolished Federal Hall in New York, where Washington had been sworn in as the nation’s first president in 1789. The brick sidewalks and cobblestone parts of the neighborhood’s streets were original; to hide the asphalt pavement, the crews carted in tons of straw mixed with dirt.
The moviemakers also focused on the long, hot summer of debate on the Constitution over which Washington presided. To keep out the noises of the 20th century streets surrounding Independence Hall, the crews filmed after midnight. Millions of candlewatts of lighting shone directly on the building to create daytime. The windows were shut, just as they had been during the Constitutional Convention in 1787 -- now to reduce the sound of generators, then to keep nosy citizens from listening to the debates going on inside.
Getting It Right
Not every Philadelphian is an expert on the city’s history. The difference is that Philadelphians insist that the people paid to present that history to visitors get it right.
After complaints reached City Hall that many of the carriage drivers and tour bus guides were not being factual in their presentations, an ordinance was proposed to test and license guides. In true Philadelphia fashion, the targeted guides countered that their First Amendment rights were being violated. Yet, their campaign to gather support among the populace for their cause fell flat, and sympathy with accuracy won out.
Most tourists visit Independence Hall, the Liberty Bell and the other places on the mall that are either originals or re-creations. When the National Park Service has no original plans for re-creation, it won’t rebuild and that often leaves huge gaps in the story.
The house in which Ben Franklin spent his last years, on Market Street near Third, is one such piece of history for which plans were not available for a re-creation. Instead, just a frame or “ghost structure,” designed by the Venturi-Scott Brown architectural firm, was substituted.
That wasn’t enough, not for so key a figure in the city’s history. So a below-ground museum tells Franklin’s story, and does it in a way that pleases children and adults, and probably would have tickled Franklin, too.