499 Real Estate Listings in Shelter Island, NY

We found 499 homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY. You can narrow your real estate listings search result for homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY by selecting specific neighborhoods, price ranges or beds/baths. You can also search homes for sale by property type, such as houses, condos or land in the Shelter Island, NY area.

Showing 15 of 15 out of 499 on the map
loading

Loading …

or jump to page

64 Burns Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family, Built in 190012 br
12 ba
12,000 sf ($1,575/sf)
FEATURED$18,900,000
Listing provided by: Sotheby's International RealtySotheby's International Realty
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

1 Bayview Avenue

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
4 ba
FEATURED$1,250,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069763:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info

20 South Menantic Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
2 ba
FEATURED$1,395,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

20 Hilo Drive

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
4 ba
FEATURED$2,895,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

37 East Brander Parkway

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family5 br
4 full 1 half ba
FEATURED$2,945,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069763:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info

22 New York Avenue

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
2 full 1 half ba
FEATURED$795,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

39 Country Club Drive

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family3 br
2 full 1 half ba
FEATURED$674,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

43 Lake Drive

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
3 ba
FEATURED$1,145,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069763:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info
 

3 Johnston Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family3 br
2 ba
FEATURED$695,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

12A Sunshine Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family5 br
5 ba
FEATURED$1,975,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

8 Cove Way

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family3 br
2 full 1 half ba
FEATURED$1,965,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069763:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info

50 Peconic Avenue

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
3 ba
FEATURED$2,875,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

151 North Ferry Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family6 br
3 full 1 half ba
FEATURED$1,900,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069763:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info

40 Brander Parkway

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
2 ba
FEATURED$599,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069786:-72.339149
Map Display
More Info

7 Quail Run

Shelter Island, NY 11964Single Family4 br
3 ba
FEATURED$725,000
Listing provided by: The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group
  
41.069778:-72.339157
Map Display
More Info
or jump to page
Location
search
What You've Selected
Use the filters below to narrow the search results
Type of Sale
Property Type
All Property Types
Search Settings
Price Range
Price Min. ($)Any Price
Price Max. ($)Any Price
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
Bedrooms Any
Bathrooms Any
Square Feet Reset
Amenities
No Preference
Age of Home
to
Open Houses
Virtual Tours
 
You are currently searching real estate listings in Shelter Island, NY. Use FrontDoor's real estate guides for first time home buyers to gain neighborly advice on the real estate process while you search homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY. FrontDoor also features other guides on real estate topics like buying a home, selling a home, home finance, moving, and Shelter Island, NY foreclosed homes for sale. Use FrontDoor tools on current mortgage rates and mortgage calculators to determine your homes for sale search range in Shelter Island, NY. If your home is for sale , take advantage of articles and videos to learn tips and tricks on home value to increase your chances of a quick sale. Search FrontDoor's foreclosure listings in Shelter Island, NY to find deals on your next home or investment opportunity. Refine your real estate search in Shelter Island, NY by neighborhood, price, number of bedrooms, number of bathrooms, property type (including townhomes in Shelter Island, NY, condominiums in Shelter Island, NY and single-family homes in Shelter Island, NY).
Level 2 Level 5 Level 8 Level 11 Level 13 Level 15
or close